Call: 1-855-937-4600  ·  NY: (631) 423-6199  ·  FL: (813) 723-1723
Licensed in All 50 States · Est. 1989
Our Story

About Plans Plus Benefits

A second-generation, family-owned brokerage that has been helping businesses take care of their people since 1989.

Who We Are

Full-service brokerage
since 1989

Plans Plus Benefits is a full-service employee benefits brokerage specializing in group insurance solutions for businesses of all sizes. With offices in New York and Florida and licenses in all 50 states, we serve clients nationwide.

♥

Comprehensive Benefits

Group health, dental, vision, life insurance, 401(k), pension plans, workers’ compensation, and property & casualty coverage — all under one roof.

⚑

Family-Owned, Client-Focused

Now in our second generation of family ownership, we treat every client like family. Our relationships span decades because we earn our place at the table every year.

☆

Two Offices, National Reach

Headquartered on Long Island, NY with a second office in the Tampa Bay area of Florida. Licensed and active in all 50 states.

1989Year founded
35+Years in business
2Generations
50States licensed
“We don’t just sell insurance — we build benefits programs that help businesses attract, retain, and protect their most valuable asset: their people.”
Our Team

Meet the people behind
your benefits

Two generations of expertise dedicated to finding the right coverage for your business and your employees.

Jesse Peltz

Jesse Peltz

Chief Executive Officer

Second-generation owner who has been active in the business since 2012. Jesse leads the firm with a deep focus on group employee benefits, helping employers navigate an increasingly complex insurance landscape. He works hands-on with clients to design packages that balance cost, coverage, and employee satisfaction.

☎ (631) 423-6199 x2
Group Benefits Expert
Arnie Peltz

Arnie Peltz

Founder

Arnie founded Plans Plus Benefits in 1989 and built the company from the ground up. While he has stepped back from day-to-day operations, he remains involved and continues to specialize in Medicare — earning him the nickname “The Medicare Whisperer” among clients and colleagues alike.

☎ (631) 423-6199 x5
The Medicare Whisperer
What Drives Us

Our core values

Everything we do is guided by three principles that have defined our business for over 35 years.

⚖

Integrity

We tell you what you need to hear, not what you want to hear. Honest advice and full transparency on costs, coverage, and carrier options — every single time.

♡

Relationships

We don’t do transactions. We build long-term partnerships with our clients, many of whom have been with us for decades. Your success is our success.

✓

Results

At the end of the day, it’s about getting you better coverage at a better price. We shop the entire market to deliver real, measurable savings for your business.

Work with us

Ready to talk benefits?

Whether you’re shopping for the first time or looking for a better deal on your current plan, we’re here to help — and our services are always free to the employer.

Request a Free Quote → Call 1-855-937-4600